Ten films with “F**k you and the horse you rode in on” speeches

There’s all kinds of movie speeches–the inspirational speech, the redemption speech, the condemnatory speech, and the romantic plea for love speech. But one of my favorites is what you might call the “F**k you and the horse you rode in on” speech. The most typical version of this speech happens towards the end of the film. The protagonist looks to be completely finished, his or her hopes to finish the quest, hopeless.

The antagonist though wants one more thing out of his or her adversary–a plea for mercy, an admission of folly, or a confession that they are, indeed, defeated. The protagonist, though, refuses to give in. Whether he wins or loses, he’s going to fight on. Even if she’s crushed, she’ll go down fighting. And that’s we they give their disquisition on defiance, their expression of apostasy, their treatise on temerity. Whether their defiant speech is followed by practical success on the battlefield is less relevant than the hero’s demonstration of his or her indomitable spirit.

Movie speeches hold a special place in the hearts and imaginations of moviegoers. One reason why is how easy they are to recreate at any moment. There are any number of cinematic elements that can make a film stand out, and one of the most memorable for viewers is a dramatic or remarkable speech. One of the reasons people love movie speeches is that they are an easy way to mimic and reenact moments in a film. It’s not practical or even possible to improvise the recreation of a film’s iconic high angle shot, lighting, or setting, but if you know the lines and have a disposition for the dramatic, you can recreate a famous speech anytime you like.

Another Top Ten List, because who doesn’t love a good listicle.

I created a list of ten clips below from ten different films with defining defiant moments. When creating the list, I created some soft criteria for determining which speeches could make my list.

  1. I tried to pick defiant speeches where the speaker was addressing the adversary directly. So, for example, the President’s speech in Independence Day (1996) is addressed to his compatriots, so that wouldn’t work for this particular list.
  2. I wanted speeches, not just lines, whenever possible, so one-liners wouldn’t work for this particular list either.
  3. I wasn’t looking for speeches that were more lectures, condemnations, or attempts at persuasion, so, for example, Rupert Cadell’s speech (Jimmy Stewart) at the end of Rope (1948) wouldn’t do it. To make this list, the speech needs to primarily be an act of defiance. To be sure, the motives in the speeches below are mixed, but I wanted speeches that foregrounded that sense of defiance.
  4. This list isn’t meant to be the top 10 defiant speeches–an effort too daunting for this undertaking. It’s just meant to be 10 great ones.
  5. Most are dramatic, but at least two on this list have comedic elements.
  6. They are organized chronologically.

Mr. Smith Goes to Washington (1939)

Mr. Smith (Jimmy Stewart), the idealist, fighting for a lost cause, the only causes worth fighting for.

On the Waterfront (1954)

A story of defiance against the mafia, and the courage to fight them when there’s not much more to lose.

Paths of Glory (1957)

Paths of Glory is a film about a colonel who fights a hopeless cause, and then when all hope is lost, he fights some more.

A Raisin in the Sun (1961)

A story about “plain and simple people” who won’t be pushed around. The ending of A Raisin in the Sun.

Inherit the Wind (1960)

A story about tolerance and an unflinching dedication to free thinking and free discourse.

My Fair Lady (1964)

This song is one of the most dignified ways I’ve ever heard anyone say, “F**k you, and the Horse You Rode in On.”

A Man For All Seasons (1966)

Sir Thomas Moore (Paul Scofield), at the end, deciding to relieve his mind of certain thoughts concerning the King, his title, and his second marriage.

The Front (1976)

Howard Prince (Woody Allen), deciding to not answer Congressional questions, in a particularly memorable fashion.

Henry V (1989)

Note to self: sporting goods equipment is not a good gift for rival medieval monarchs.

Burn After Reading (2008)

A silly scene from the Coen brothers’ film, Burn After Reading (2008), but it technically fits the criteria for the list.

Which movies–and speeches–would you add to this list?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s